The rifle from the Crimean War taken from the trophy room (murder weapon)
The hauntings around the manor up until the seance (everyone who lives there notices).
The klikushestvo doll taken from the trophy room (allows Randolph to possess the murderer in the seance)
The burnt new will in Kaye's bedroom
The birth certificate of Felicity Carter stored in Kaye's bedroom
The marriage certificate of Kaye and Randolph stored in Kaye's bedroom
Drug paraphernalia found in Evelyn's room
Note about plants found out in the nursery
Note to Aleister about the phrases Evelyn uses
Note to Melancolia about noises from Lionel's manor while killing livestock
The marriage certificate of Lionel and Belladonna stored in Kaye's bedroom
Victor's quote on buying Lionel's manor
Note to Victor about Faust & Felicity's bodies and autopsy
Note to Gwyneth about Ortensia's theft
Note to Melancolia about Victor's grave robbing
Servant rumours about Victor's lurking
Note about stitches on Aleister's neck
Servant rumours about Aleister's indulgences
Note about being bitten by Melancolia
Note to Cain about seeing dead animals
Note to Aleister about local girls seeing dead animals
Servant rumours about gunshot heard on the moors when both Cain and Randolph were out
Servant rumours about Cain's lurking
Servant rumours about Gwyneth's gambling
Note to Aleister about money won from Gwyneth
Note about money being given to Gwyneth in Kaye's diary in bedroom